Supreme Court Rules On Case Involving Identity Theft Penalty Enhancement Act…

Supreme Court Rules On Case Involving Identity Theft Penalty Enhancement Act…

The Biden administration has lost yet another case before the U.S. Supreme Court in a rare unanimous decision.

Justices ruled 9-0 last week to limit “the reach of the federal Identity Theft Penalty Enhancement Act, unanimously rebuffing the Biden administration’s efforts to prosecute a man already convicted of Medicaid fraud with a separate charge of aggravated identity theft arising out of the same fraud case,” The Epoch Times reported.

The ruling, Dubin v. United States, was authored by Justice Sonia Sotomayor, and Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote a concurring opinion.

The Epoch Times noted further:

The Identity Theft Penalty Enhancement Act mandates a two-year prison sentence for violations.

When President George W. Bush signed the law in 2004, he said it established the federal “offense of aggravated identity theft” to ensure that someone convicted of that crime would receive jail time “for stealing a person’s good name.”

These punishments will come on top of any punishment for crimes that proceed from identity theft,” Bush said then, adding it “raises the standard of conduct for people who have access to personal records through their work at banks, government agencies, insurance companies, and other storehouses of financial data.”

However, the Supreme Court rejected the argument put forth by the U.S. Department of Justice that petitioner David Fox Dubin was automatically guilty under the act due to the inclusion of the patient’s Medicaid reimbursement number as a “means of identification” on a fraudulent Medicaid billing form.

Dubin held the position of managing partner at PARTS, a company based in Austin, Texas, which was established by his father, licensed psychologist William Dubin. Both individuals were convicted by a U.S. district court for their involvement in a scheme to defraud the Medicaid program in the Lone Star State.

Medicaid is a program that operates jointly at the federal and state levels, catering to individuals of all ages who have limited income. The program’s specifics may differ from state to state, as state and local governments administer it in accordance with federal guidelines. Each state has the authority to establish its own eligibility criteria and determine the range of services provided under the program.

Constrained by the precedent set by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit, the U.S. district court upheld Dubin’s conviction for aggravated identity theft, despite recognizing that the central focus of the case was fraudulent billing rather than identity theft. In March 2022, a divided 5th Circuit affirmed the conviction, even though it acknowledged that, per the government’s interpretation of the act, “the elements of [the] offense are not captured or even fairly described by the words ‘identity theft.
Jeffrey L. Fisher, a professor at Stanford Law School and Dubin’s attorney, said he was satisfied with the ruling.

“We’re grateful for the Court’s decision for Mr. Dubin’s sake and are pleased in general that the Court has reined in the prosecutorial overreaching the statute allowed,” he told The Epoch Times.

The case goes back to 2013, when Dubin filed a claim with Medicaid for $540 for services provided to someone identified as Patient L. The government didn’t dispute that the psychological examination practice treated the patient or had the authority to use the patient’s name in the billing process, according to Dubin’s petition (pdf) that was filed with the Supreme Court in June 2022.

“Instead, the government’s theory was that [the] petitioner overbilled Medicaid for the services provided,” which was enough to be convicted of health care fraud, the petition said.

“But the government was not content with that conviction. It also indicted [the] petitioner for aggravated identity theft,” the petition added. The Biden administration’s position was that Dubin was in violation of the ID theft statute because he placed Patient L’s “identifying information on the fraudulent Medicaid claim form.”

Related Posts

Did you know that if you eat BANANA EVERY DAY your body can… See more in first comment 🤯

Bananas are among the most popular fruits in the world, loved for their natural sweetness, convenience, and impressive nutritional profile. But as with any food, the question…

Over 23 million Americans on edge as scientists WARN of violent earthquake looming Scientists have issued an alarming new warning about a massive earthquake that could impact over 23 million Americans — and it could strike sooner than anyone thought 😳 🚨 Full urgent details are in the comments below

Scientists believe a significant earthquake in Southern California this week may have an unexpected cause, yet it has rekindled fears of the ‘Big One’. Stretching more than…

If you eat EGG every day

The Benefits and Risks of Eating Eggs Eggs are a highly nutritious food that has been a fundamental part of the human diet for centuries. They are…

She Wrecked My Marriage But My Rev:enge Was Deliciously Inevitable

Betrayal happens in many forms, but few wounds cut as deep as being defrauded by those closest to us. When family motions become toxic, the fallout can…

10 Small Acts of Kindness That Changed Someone’s Life Forever

We often assume that life-changing moments demand noble indication or big, dramatic actions, but sometimes the smallest acts of kindness can have the deepestimpact. A simple word…

12 Times Family Secrets Turned Out to Be Sh0cking Plot Twists

Family secrets can lurk in the shadows, ranging from harmless tales whispered at reunions to earth-shattering truths that shake your very foundation. We grow up believing our…

Leave a Reply